Artificial intelligence is everywhere. It can write essays, analyse complex information, create images, recognise patterns and answer questions on almost any subject imaginable. Every few months, another technological breakthrough arrives, accompanied by increasingly impressive claims about what machines can achieve.
And I have to admit, some of it is extraordinary. But I can’t help thinking that in our excitement about artificial intelligence, we’re overlooking something even more remarkable.
The best AI in the world has been around for millions of years: Animal Intelligence.
And unlike artificial intelligence, it doesn’t need a software update every few weeks.
Intelligence Doesn’t Have to Look Like Ours
Humans have a tendency to judge intelligence by comparing it with our own.
Can an animal understand words? Can it count? Can it solve puzzles? Can it follow instructions?
These are interesting questions, but they reveal something about our assumptions. We often measure other species against human abilities rather than appreciating the extraordinary skills they have developed to survive in their own environments.
A dog doesn’t need to understand algebra to demonstrate intelligence. A migratory bird doesn’t need to read a map. An elephant doesn’t need a mobile phone to communicate across considerable distances.
And a bee certainly doesn’t need to understand the complexities of human mathematics to do something that once seemed surprisingly sophisticated for an insect.
In 2018, researchers published evidence that honeybees could understand zero as a numerical quantity, placing an empty set below sets containing objects.
Think about that for a moment. A creature with a brain weighing roughly a milligram can demonstrate an understanding of numerical absence.
Meanwhile, people occasionally needed a calculator to work out a restaurant tip.
The Dog’s Nose: A Biological Technology We Still Struggle to Replicate
Of all the remarkable abilities found in animals, the dog’s sense of smell is one of my favourites.
Dogs experience the world through scent in ways we can barely imagine. Where we might notice the smell of freshly cut grass, a dog can investigate a complex mixture of chemical information left by other animals, people and the surrounding environment. But the capabilities of the canine nose go far beyond finding a dropped biscuit.
Researchers have investigated whether trained dogs can detect cancer through changes in the chemical composition of human breath and other biological samples.
In a study published in Integrative Cancer Therapies in 2006, trained dogs identified lung cancer from breath samples with a reported sensitivity and specificity of approximately 99%. The same study reported 88% sensitivity and 98% specificity for breast cancer. Those are extraordinary results.
They don’t mean dogs have replaced medical screening, or that canine cancer detection is consistently more accurate than established diagnostic equipment. Larger studies, standardised methods and reliable clinical validation remain important challenges.
But they do demonstrate something remarkable: a dog’s biological sensory system can identify disease-associated chemical patterns that humans cannot consciously detect.
We invest enormous resources into developing increasingly sophisticated sensors, yet evolution has already produced a detection system capable of feats that continue to inspire scientific research.
And then, having demonstrated this astonishing biological capability, the same animal may spend five minutes investigating an apparently fascinating lamppost. Perhaps intelligence is also about knowing what matters to you.
Birds That Navigate Without GPS
Consider migratory birds. Some species travel thousands of miles between breeding and wintering grounds, navigating across landscapes and oceans without road signs, satellites or Google Maps.
Their navigational abilities involve several sources of information, including the sun, stars, landmarks and Earth’s magnetic field. The magnetic sense is particularly fascinating.
Research suggests that light-sensitive proteins called cryptochromes may contribute to a biological compass in the eyes of migratory birds. Experiments have demonstrated that cryptochrome 4 from European robins responds to magnetic fields under laboratory conditions, supporting a possible mechanism involving quantum chemistry.
The precise biological mechanism remains an active area of research, but the ability of birds to use magnetic information for orientation is well established.
A living creature can use information from the planet’s magnetic field to help navigate journeys that would leave many humans completely lost without their phones. And it manages all of this without announcing, “Recalculating route.”
Elephants That Communicate Through the Ground
Elephants offer another remarkable example of animal intelligence and sensory adaptation. Their communication extends beyond the sounds we can hear.
Elephants produce low-frequency vocalisations, some of which generate vibrations that travel through the ground. Research has demonstrated that elephants can detect and respond to seismic signals, including information associated with alarm calls.
Their sensitivity to these vibrations provides another potential channel of communication alongside airborne sound.
Imagine receiving information through the ground beneath your feet. No mobile network. No text message. No notification sound. Just an extraordinary combination of anatomy, sensory processing and behaviour developed through evolution. And unlike most group chats, the information might actually be important.
Your Dog Is Doing More Thinking Than You Realise
We don’t have to look to exotic wildlife to appreciate animal intelligence. Sometimes we only need to watch the dog sitting beside us.
Dogs learn from experience, recognise patterns, form associations and adjust their behaviour according to their surroundings. They can become extraordinarily good at anticipating human routines.
Your dog may recognise the difference between you picking up your car keys to leave for work and picking up the same keys before a trip to the park.
They may notice subtle changes in your posture, movement or behaviour before you have consciously realised you’re communicating anything.
They are constantly gathering information. And this brings us to something particularly important in dog training.
Intelligence is not the same as obedience.
We often describe a dog as intelligent because it learns commands quickly or performs impressive tricks.
But a dog that doesn’t follow an instruction isn’t necessarily less intelligent. It may be frightened, frustrated, distracted, physically uncomfortable or overwhelmed.
A dog that barks and lunges at another dog isn’t necessarily demonstrating poor intelligence. It may be responding to an emotional state that makes alternative behaviour difficult.
Equally, a dog that remains perfectly still isn’t necessarily relaxed. The outward behaviour doesn’t always tell us what is happening internally. This distinction is fundamental to how I approach canine behaviour.
Understanding the Intelligence Behind the Behaviour
The Calm Dog Framework is built around understanding the individual dog rather than simply trying to control what we see.
A dog’s behaviour is influenced by its nervous system, emotional state, previous experiences, physical health, environment and relationships.
These factors interact constantly. When a dog becomes highly aroused, frightened or frustrated, its ability to respond flexibly and learn may be affected.
That doesn’t mean the dog has suddenly become less intelligent. It means its nervous system is responding to the demands of the situation. Good training recognises this.
We first seek to understand the dog and create conditions in which learning can take place. Only then do we select appropriate training and behaviour-change strategies.
The aim isn’t simply to produce an animal that follows instructions. It’s to support an individual capable of navigating the human world with greater confidence, emotional stability and behavioural flexibility.
And perhaps one of the most intelligent things humans can do is recognise that another species doesn’t have to think like us to deserve our understanding.
Perhaps We Should Be a Little More Humble
I find artificial intelligence fascinating. I use it myself, and I believe it has enormous potential to improve how we learn, research and communicate.
But there’s something wonderfully ironic about the excitement surrounding machines that can recognise patterns, process information and adapt their responses.
Animals have been doing their own extraordinary versions of these things for millions of years.
Dogs can detect chemical information associated with disease. Birds can navigate using the Earth’s magnetic field. Elephants can detect information carried through the ground. Even honeybees have demonstrated numerical abilities that challenge our assumptions about tiny brains.
None of this means that animals and computers possess the same kind of intelligence, or that one can simply replace the other.
It means intelligence is far more varied, specialised and fascinating than we sometimes appreciate.
Perhaps the greatest lesson isn’t that animal intelligence is superior to artificial intelligence in every respect.
It’s that we have spent an extraordinary amount of time trying to create intelligence while still learning to understand the intelligence that already surrounds us.
So, by all means, let’s celebrate artificial intelligence. But let’s not forget the original AI. Animal Intelligence.
Millions of years in development, endlessly adaptable, and still capable of surprising us. Although, in fairness, my dogs have yet to produce a properly formatted spreadsheet.